Dry farming alfalfa is a real but narrow tool in Utah, and it works best as part of a paid-leasing system rather than as a standalone crop strategy. Lease-based, partial-season approaches look cheaper and more flexible than going fully dryland. I asked Claude if this idea makes sense for leasing water for the lake and getting more bang for the buck. Dry farming is not binary or digital, yes or no. It's an economic gradient or spectrum with a maximum, minimum and a optimal point on the curve. Solve the equation.
Why it matters now: The lake is sitting just over a foot above its 2022 record low after a dry winter and hot summer. Agriculture uses about 65% of the water that would otherwise flow to the lake, and much of the basin's farmland grows alfalfa.
What the agronomy says
- Alfalfa's water use is front-loaded. The first cutting needs about 5 acre-inches of evapotranspiration per ton, versus about 7 for later cuttings. Dropping the 3rd and 4th cuttings saves the least efficient water. usu
- USU trials near Logan show the tradeoff. A 25% cut in irrigation reduced yield about 20%, and a 50% cut reduced it about 30%. usu
- Fully dryland is much harsher. One regional review found average yields of 16.6 Mg/ha fully irrigated, 11.1 under deficit irrigation, and 6.0 under dryland conditions. Water-use efficiency also falls as irrigation is reduced. statestate
- Dryland varieties exist, but they're bred for 12–18 inches of annual precipitation. Much of the Great Salt Lake basin farmland is drier than that, so realistically you'd get one cutting, sometimes two, in wetter benches and higher valleys like parts of Cache Valley (my own judgment, not from the sources). usu
- Alfalfa is forgiving. It generally survives short periods without irrigation and recovers when watered again. That makes rotating fields in and out of production feasible. escholarship
What the state buying water adds
- Law: HB 410 created the Great Salt Lake Preservation Program, which compensates farmers for temporarily leasing part of their water rights. Full-season leasing is limited to two of every five years. utah
- Funding and timing: Lawmakers put $2.75 million into it, and it won't be available until 2027. Payments are meant to track commodity prices, and water closer to the lake pays more. That is probably the closest thing to "less effective water" being priced differently. Great Salt Lake commish eager to tap new water law to bolster the lake +2
- Cost: The state's basin plan puts ending alfalfa irrigation early or full-season leasing at about $236 per acre-foot, and alfalfa-to-winter-wheat at $276. Phragmites removal runs $610–$4,050 per acre-foot. By that measure, leasing is one of the cheaper options. utahsltrib
- Scale: A balanced mix of leasing, irrigation upgrades and crop substitution could cut Utah-side agricultural depletion 10% (about 83,000 acre-feet) for roughly $30M a year. Researchers have said the basin needs about 650,000 acre-feet a year less consumption to reach a healthy lake. At about $236 per acre-foot, that would be on the order of $150M a year (my arithmetic, which ignores price rises as supply tightens). The current program's roughly $2.75M buys about 10,000–12,000 acre-feet, so it is a pilot, not a solution. utahidahocapitalsun
Key caveats
- Only consumptive savings count. A project can save water on paper while the crop still consumes the same amount, and what matters to the lake is the consumed amount. Leases and dry-down should be measured as reduced evapotranspiration, not reduced diversions. sltrib
- Delivery: The saved water has to be legally dedicated and protected from being diverted by others downstream. HB 410 addresses diversion by an intervening user of leased water. utah
- Farmer buy-in: The Salt Lake Tribune has reported that farmers are skeptical about water leasing. Concerns include losing water rights, thin margins, and dairy and hay market ties. Flexible terms matter, since a key advantage of leasing over mandates is that each irrigator can choose, such as switching to dryland on part of a field. sltribusu
Other perspectives: Supporters see voluntary leasing as the lowest-cost, least coercive route that keeps farms operating. Critics, including some environmental groups, argue it is too small and slow, and that enforceable cutbacks are needed. Some also worry about fallowed or stressed fields causing dust, and about rural economic effects if too much acreage idles
Dry farming
another crop: winter wheat
· Established system: Dryland wheat is a long-standing practice in
northern Utah. USU research runs on winter wheat–fallow systems, planted in
October at sites such as the Blue Creek Dryland Experimental Station and a farm
near Snowville. In that system, a field is cropped one year and left fallow the
next. usu
· Challenges: USU describes limited water, declining soil fertility and low
organic matter as the main constraints on dryland wheat. High input costs and
lower yields have pushed some farmers toward low-input organic systems. usu
· Soil building: A single 22-ton-per-acre compost application
improved soil moisture and aggregate stability (up 143%), and wheat yields were
nearly double 28 years later. The upfront cost is high. usu
· Other dryland options: USU has also tested safflower varieties
alongside winter wheat for dryland production in northern Utah, including how
each responds to larger, less frequent storms. reeis
· Comparison with alfalfa (my judgment, not from
the sources): Wheat fits
dryland better because it is an annual that finishes its growth on stored soil
moisture and spring rain. It needs no repeated cuttings. It also earns less per
acre and would save less lake-bound water than retiring irrigated alfalfa,
which matters for the leasing approach above.





