Sunday, November 22, 2026

Digital Dry Farming in Utah for the Great Salt Lake

Dry farming alfalfa is a real but narrow tool in Utah, and it works best as part of a paid-leasing system rather than as a standalone crop strategy. Lease-based, partial-season approaches look cheaper and more flexible than going fully dryland.  I asked Claude if this idea makes sense for leasing water for the lake and getting more bang for the buck.  Dry farming is not binary or digital, yes or no.  It's an economic gradient or spectrum with a maximum, minimum and a optimal point on the curve.  Solve the equation.

Why it matters now: The lake is sitting just over a foot above its 2022 record low after a dry winter and hot summer. Agriculture uses about 65% of the water that would otherwise flow to the lake, and much of the basin's farmland grows alfalfa.



What the agronomy says

  • Alfalfa's water use is front-loaded. The first cutting needs about 5 acre-inches of evapotranspiration per ton, versus about 7 for later cuttings. Dropping the 3rd and 4th cuttings saves the least efficient water. usu
  • USU trials near Logan show the tradeoff. A 25% cut in irrigation reduced yield about 20%, and a 50% cut reduced it about 30%. usu
  • Fully dryland is much harsher. One regional review found average yields of 16.6 Mg/ha fully irrigated, 11.1 under deficit irrigation, and 6.0 under dryland conditions. Water-use efficiency also falls as irrigation is reduced. statestate
  • Dryland varieties exist, but they're bred for 12–18 inches of annual precipitation. Much of the Great Salt Lake basin farmland is drier than that, so realistically you'd get one cutting, sometimes two, in wetter benches and higher valleys like parts of Cache Valley (my own judgment, not from the sources). usu
  • Alfalfa is forgiving. It generally survives short periods without irrigation and recovers when watered again. That makes rotating fields in and out of production feasible. escholarship

What the state buying water adds

  • Law: HB 410 created the Great Salt Lake Preservation Program, which compensates farmers for temporarily leasing part of their water rights. Full-season leasing is limited to two of every five years. utah
  • Funding and timing: Lawmakers put $2.75 million into it, and it won't be available until 2027. Payments are meant to track commodity prices, and water closer to the lake pays more. That is probably the closest thing to "less effective water" being priced differently. Great Salt Lake commish eager to tap new water law to bolster the lake +2
  • Cost: The state's basin plan puts ending alfalfa irrigation early or full-season leasing at about $236 per acre-foot, and alfalfa-to-winter-wheat at $276. Phragmites removal runs $610–$4,050 per acre-foot. By that measure, leasing is one of the cheaper options. utahsltrib
  • Scale: A balanced mix of leasing, irrigation upgrades and crop substitution could cut Utah-side agricultural depletion 10% (about 83,000 acre-feet) for roughly $30M a year. Researchers have said the basin needs about 650,000 acre-feet a year less consumption to reach a healthy lake. At about $236 per acre-foot, that would be on the order of $150M a year (my arithmetic, which ignores price rises as supply tightens). The current program's roughly $2.75M buys about 10,000–12,000 acre-feet, so it is a pilot, not a solution. utahidahocapitalsun

Key caveats

  • Only consumptive savings count. A project can save water on paper while the crop still consumes the same amount, and what matters to the lake is the consumed amount. Leases and dry-down should be measured as reduced evapotranspiration, not reduced diversions. sltrib
  • Delivery: The saved water has to be legally dedicated and protected from being diverted by others downstream. HB 410 addresses diversion by an intervening user of leased water. utah
  • Farmer buy-in: The Salt Lake Tribune has reported that farmers are skeptical about water leasing. Concerns include losing water rights, thin margins, and dairy and hay market ties. Flexible terms matter, since a key advantage of leasing over mandates is that each irrigator can choose, such as switching to dryland on part of a field. sltribusu

Other perspectives: Supporters see voluntary leasing as the lowest-cost, least coercive route that keeps farms operating. Critics, including some environmental groups, argue it is too small and slow, and that enforceable cutbacks are needed. Some also worry about fallowed or stressed fields causing dust, and about rural economic effects if too much acreage idles

Dry farming another crop: winter wheat

·       Established system: Dryland wheat is a long-standing practice in northern Utah. USU research runs on winter wheat–fallow systems, planted in October at sites such as the Blue Creek Dryland Experimental Station and a farm near Snowville. In that system, a field is cropped one year and left fallow the next. usu

·       Challenges: USU describes limited water, declining soil fertility and low organic matter as the main constraints on dryland wheat. High input costs and lower yields have pushed some farmers toward low-input organic systems. usu

·       Soil building: A single 22-ton-per-acre compost application improved soil moisture and aggregate stability (up 143%), and wheat yields were nearly double 28 years later. The upfront cost is high. usu

·       Other dryland options: USU has also tested safflower varieties alongside winter wheat for dryland production in northern Utah, including how each responds to larger, less frequent storms. reeis

·       Comparison with alfalfa (my judgment, not from the sources): Wheat fits dryland better because it is an annual that finishes its growth on stored soil moisture and spring rain. It needs no repeated cuttings. It also earns less per acre and would save less lake-bound water than retiring irrigated alfalfa, which matters for the leasing approach above.


Saturday, November 21, 2026

Wind Wind

 

 

We have been coming here to the Central Coast for 45 years and see both sides of the Morrow Bay Smokestack Issue. Should they stay or should they go.

We don’t know anything about nothing but that is sometimes a valuable point with no bias or baggage. 

 

Here are some back of the envelope Claude calculations for installing some helix type wind mills up top. It could be a wind wind situation. When they give you, lemons make lemonade. 

 



To size the turbines and calculate the annual energy output for all three Morro Bay stacks at 550 feet elevation (100 feet above the 450-foot stacks, assuming the stacks are topped by a 100-foot-tall spiral turbine), we combine commercial helical vertical-axis wind turbine (VAWT) engineering limits with the 16 to 18 mph (~7.5 m/s) coastal wind profile.

 

1.  Sizing the Ideal Turbine for Each Stack

 

Because the stacks sit in a straight line roughly 120 to 150 feet apart, the rotor diameter cannot be so wide that the blades collide or create severe wake turbulence. A 100-foot-tall lift-based helical Darrieus turbine (similar to large-scale commercial VAWT concepts like Quiet Revolution or IceWind / SeaTwirl scaled designs) is the sweet spot.

 

·       Rotor Dimensions (per stack): 100 feet tall × 50 feet wide (30.5 m × 15.2 m)

 

·       Swept Area (per turbine): 5,000 sq. ft. (~465 sq. meters)

 

·       Total Swept Area (all 3 stacks): 15,000 sq. ft. (~1,395 sq. meters)

 

·       Rated Capacity (per turbine): 250 kW (reaching peak output in ~26–28 mph winds)

 

·       Total Array Rated Capacity: 750 kW (0.75 MW)

 

·       Cut-In / Cut-Out Speeds: Starts generating at 6 mph; automatically brakes/feathers in extreme storm gusts above 55 mph.

 

2.  Annual Energy Output Calculation (All 3 Stacks)

 

Wind turbines don't run at 100% peak capacity all year; they operate at a Capacity Factor based on local wind consistency. At 650 feet on the Central Coast—where afternoon thermal sea breezes blow reliably from spring through fall—a 250 kW helical VAWT will achieve an estimated 28% to 33% capacity factor.

 

Step-by-Step Energy Math:

 

1.      Available Wind Power in the Air: At sea-level air density ($\rho \approx 1.225\text{ kg/m}^3$) and a 17 mph (7.6 m/s) annual average wind speed (accounting for standard Weibull wind speed distribution, which boosts available energy above a flat average):

 

$$P_{\text{wind}} = \frac{1}{2} \rho A v^3 \times \text{Weibull factor} \approx 260\text{ kW per turbine}$$

 

2.      Turbine Efficiency ($C_p$): Lift-based helical VAWTs capture roughly 32% to 35% of kinetic wind energy (compared to ~45% for traditional three-blade horizontal turbines), yielding an average continuous electrical output of~75 to 85 kW per stack.

 

3.      Annual Production (8,760 hours/year):

 

o   Per Stack: $80\text{ kW} \times 8,760\text{ hours} \approx \mathbf{700,000\text{ kWh}\ (700\text{ MWh})/year}$

 

o   All 3 Stacks Combined: ~2,100,000 to 2,300,000 kWh (2.1 to 2.3 GWh) per year

 

3. Real-World Context: What 2.2 GWh/Year Powers


To put that output into perspective for Morro Bay:

 

Metric

Estimated Output / Impact

Total Array Capacity

750 kW (three 250 kW helical turbines)

Annual Electricity Generated

~2.1 to 2.3 GWh (2.2 million kWh)

California Homes Powered

~320 to 500 homes continuously year-round (based on average CA household usage of ~6,500 kWh/yr) – less at the coast with no air condition

Commercial Equivalent

Roughly enough power to run all of Morro Bay's Embarcadero waterfront businesses, restaurants, and harbor operations

Counter-Rotation Bonus

Configuring the middle turbine to spin opposite the outer two can reduce wake interference and boost array efficiency by 5% to 10% (~2.4 GWh/yr total)

 

4. Key Engineering & Cost Realities for a Proposal


If you are putting together a feasibility concept or presentation, three practical numbers will ground your design:

 

·       Estimated Capital Cost: Custom high-altitude commercial VAWT installations of this scale typically run $3,500 per kW installed (plus structural stack retrofitting), putting a three-stack project in the $4 million range—a fraction of the estimated $20M+ cost to demolish the stacks.

 

·       Grid Advantage: Because the Morro Bay substation is immediately adjacent to the stacks, interconnection costs would be minimal, and peak afternoon wind generation aligns almost perfectly with California's peak afternoon/evening electricity demand (when solar begins tapering off).  No Batteries. Power could also be coordinated with Diablo power plant.  

 

I am sure they have considered something like this that maybe has gotten lost in the noise but I urge you to reconsider.  These stacks can morph from historical eye sore to a functional attraction.  Painted pink and blue, tourist can charge their E-cars from the wind while shopping in the green downtown. 

 

I’m sure there are regulation challenges and dozens of reasons and excuses not to do this but there is only one reason to do it.  It works.  It makes sense.  It would be fun 

 

 Costa Rica has made tourism marketing giant steps for being a green country (without an army) and you could too.  This could be better than the Otters.  When they give you mayo, make mayonnaise.

 

Make it so.  Just do it.  

 

Thursday, November 19, 2026

Wheels and Water

We drive down to the little surf town of Cayucos, the town that time forgot on the Central Coast of California, in the fall when the coast is clear, during the shoulder season at home when everyone is obsessed with snow.  They turn on the ocean just before we get here, just like they did last year and the year before.  The ocean view is always changing with every 11 second wave set, but the landscape remains the same with just the land, sea and sky.  The land around this little town has all been preserved for 100 miles and there are cows on the hills, not condos, birds on the beach, not blankets and whales in the water, not oil wells.

Generated image

The drive here is everchanging and half of the fun.  In the ten years since we started coming to the Central Coast consistently, they have improved at least five sections of industrial two-lane rural roads to freeway capacity highways.  They see a problem and they fix it.  Big time.  They take years and millions of dollars to build a parallel new road alignment and then abandon the old road and build another two lanes.  They imaginatively move the rolling curvy alignment to the hills, straightening it horizontally and vertically over hill and dale, thru farmlands proactively, before they become subdivisions, with big time cuts and fill, bridges, culverts and intersections that will last 100 years.

They must.  There are 40 million people in California who drive a billion miles a day.  That is real milage when you scale it.  It is the intersection of the supply and demand curves, the scale of diminishing returns and the inverse of the economy of scale where there is so much demand that it makes it inefficient to try to keep up.  But they try.  40 million people in a one hour traffic jam costs 4 billion dollars a day or a trillion dollars a year.  That’s real money and worth the investment to avoid.  In Oregon and Maine they all drive 45 mph on old two lane cattle roads, but no one really goes that fast.  In Utah they study and debate improvements until the land is gone and the price is high, and then they compromise with half ass solutions that will last ten years. 

This year the ocean is warmer than normal, from El Nino and global warming, the Kelvin surge and a 5000-mile, solar powered westerly wind fetch, unimpeded all the way from Russia.  You don’t even need a wet suit to go swimming for the first time, ever.  This year has been compounded with 20–30-foot waves, measured on the backside, from a storm near Alaska that are 50-60-foot at favored locations like Mavericks and are eating up the beaches, sea walls and access stairs.  It feels like a harmonic convergence of the sea, just as we started paying attention to it.  The locals talk about the surf like we talk about snow, inside - outside, left - right, tow in - shore break, back door – washing machine.  It is the lexicon of a dying culture that is priced out by million dollar second homes, limited access and changing climate. 

I love to study the surf lexicon but limit my old-man involvement to Boogie boarding the shore break in a Farmer John shorty wetsuit that is easy in and easy out.  It is what I am left with along with riding e-bikes, skiing sunny corduroy and playing Pickleball.  I wait in waist deep water for the celerity waves – fast waves over the top of slow waves – that double up and give me a big, long surge to the beach.   Going out any deeper puts me uncontrollably over my head and in the crash zone with the waves breaking on me every 11 seconds.  Going outside with fins is even harder where catching waves awkwardly requires courage and backbone when they go left and I go right and they break on my spine.  I still have so much to learn about reading and riding and it is fun to be a novice again.

Sea temperatures are 15 degrees above average and a turning point for the big ocean heat sink of the planet as it catches up with atmospheric warming.  The fat tides are high and the beach is flooded at times, precluding our morning walks.  Only our dog does not understand, and a few Orange County climate deniers.  Is this a pivot point where the oceans no longer protect us but rather take over.  With the melting poles and changing currents who knows what normal is anymore, but it seems to me more is happening than just El Nino.

Generated image

The endless almond groves we passed through in the central valley, that had no water, were dying while some with better water rights looked good.  Meanwhile the hills are winter green with all the rain we have had, even the Diamond desert, and it looks like the world is one lucky dry farm that is blooming, for now, without irrigation.  The age of free water is ending in the west so they will stop growing rice and cotton in the desert and irrigate pasture at 8000 feet.  Perhaps dry farming is the answer with our new rain hydrology when severe winter storms juice up the land differently.  Perhaps this is an evolutionary inflection point for all species where things change with a lurch and a scream instead of slowly, with a whimper.  We must go higher, deeper, faster, smarter.  Resilience. Adapt.  Evolve. They must keep up or go extinct.  So do we.

We wonder at California’s climate and transportation problems and changes, solutions and resolutions for we know they are coming our way.  They are progressive here, outside of the Central Valley, and they try new, different, weird, outside-the-box things with traffic and transportation, water and public welfare and fix or accept the unintended consequences.   Will our technology help us keep up or will it doom us inevitably. 

Our existential crisis’s of climate and Ai come together on my keyboard where every query for a deep solution exacerbates the problem by requiring more water and energy.  We limited our use of the Atomic Bomb, and stopped numbering our modern wars, after two each, but can we harness control from our fluids, phones, cars and computers?  If necessity is the mother of invention and supply, then who is your demand daddy of application and resolution.  Self-control and discipline?  Hope and empathy?  Evolution and enlightenment?

Tuesday, November 3, 2026

Surely Looks Like Rain

 

With El Nino ragging thru the southern states and Climate Changing performing as advertised, with more frequent extreme events, it is no wonder that the weather is the main event on the evening news, even with all the Tomfoolery in Washington DC.  The entire ocean is record warm now, not only the Southern Oscillation, as this massive heat sink lag catches up with the systemic heating of our atmosphere.  Huge floods and runoff events have inundated rivers, have filled some local lakes and even added 4-6% capacity to Lake Powell.  (This is nice but Lake Powell needs 10 feet of snow over 100,000 square miles to fill again.  Snowpack fills our big dams.) Some people seem surprised at these events, but they have been prophesied by engineers, meteorologists and hydrologist prognosticators for the last 75 years as maximum possible storms, 40 years as Climate Change and 2 years as El Nino.  


Back in the day we used to design dams for the Probable Maximum Flood (PMF) from the Probable Maximum Precipitation (PMP) because Probable Maximum Storm (PMS) was already taken. There was no rational reason for a high hazard dam, one capable of killing someone, to breach because you couldn’t forecast max floods or you saved money on a cheap emergency overflow spillway.  This PMF was the Deterministic, proverbial line in the sand, million-year flood.  These floods were used to design dangerous large dams, volatile nuclear power plants, prized golf courses and grandma’s rose garden, depending on your priorities.  It took a lot of money and disproportionate resources to provide this level of protection at all dams.  A big dam would not fail in a max storm but all the schools in the floodplain would wash away in the successfully routed flood.  There was lop-sided spending and no one to insure risk consistency between all the hazards we face. 

To calculate the PMP for a dam, we would look at all the biggest historical storms and largest ones the atmosphere of the last 10,000 years could possibly physically produce in a drainage basin.  Then we would maximize them, to account for things like climate change, politics, economics, error bias, and the things that we didn’t know that we didn’t know.  We weren’t even allowed to say the words climate change back then, so we didn’t feel too bad about rounding up.

The PMP for Utah came from a storm near Morgan in 1958 that dropped 6 inches of rain in 45 minutes.  There were full buckets, barrels and hubcaps that proved that it rained hard and anecdotal tales, but there was no paleo evidence of a PMF that would result from rain like that (like a stick, rock or cat stuck high up in a tree).  Sometimes the PMP would not give you the PMF depending on temporal or spatial distribution of the storm, the antecedent saturation or post-apocalyptic burn scars in the watershed.  But the storm, that formed from two colliding thunder cells, was extrapolated by NWS-NOAA on paper to 72 hours over 200 square miles and became the design anchor storm for the intermountain west.  That’s when dam spillways got real expensive

We spent a ton of money on spillways to the point where the new Trial Lake Dam spillway was bigger than the Jordanelle Dam spillway and sometimes the design spillway was bigger than the dam.  Something had to give.  Dam engineers started to look at a more consistent, Probabilistic approach that considered dam breach flood risks with all the other non-voluntary risks in society and tried to spend the money where we could get the most bang for the buck.  We also looked at Significant Incremental Damage Thresholds for inflow floods that were bigger than potential dam breach floods, when no one would care. Terms like ‘acceptable risk’ and the ‘cost-to-save-a-life’ got around the fact that we were putting a value on human life.  This didn’t seem too bad since the probabilities were very small. 

But these rare breach events would happen, and we didn’t want to be the cold, callus, calculating engineer siting on the witness stand telling the widow why her family was killed so we could save money.  So, the burden of determining acceptable risk was put on our elected officials who, of course, chose to punt.  We depend on vague ideas of ‘Industry Standards’, ‘Act of God’ and the But-For defense where a failure would have happened no matter what we had done.  This was a small comfort for engineers and hydrologists who would be hung out to dry anyhow.  Doctors put their mistakes in graveyards, lawyers put theirs in jail, while engineers and hydrologists hang their dirty laundry out on the line for all the world to see.

With the increased frequency of severe storms, as we predicted 40 years ago, we must come to terms with seeing a 100-year flood every 5 years.  We have come through the Stewardship periods of Environmentalism - which then got a bad radical name, Sustainability – which got overused at colleges, Adaptability – implying surrender, and Resilience – implying toughness.  Now we have Discontinuity, Disassociation or Sui Generis – where what is happening now has nothing to do with what happened before.  That is what is happening with our atmosphere, climate and storms.

Our Probabilistic models have no relevant historical data to decipher anymore, and we must go back to our Deterministic models that physically simulate the atmosphere, the drainage basins and the river channels with pixelated, finite elements that make up our hydrologic systems.  Slap some NextRad radar over some GIS terrain models and out pops the flood.  Luckily these models are good enough and computers are fast enough, with Ai assistance, to help model these things as they happen.  We now have 2D and 3D models that help with Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD).  With quantum computers there will be no coincidences and there should be no surprises with real-time forecasting.  Necessity is the mother….  The proverbial PMP-PMF line in the sand may be moving, figuratively and virtually, but at least we should be able to keep up with it.  Even a blind man knows when it is raining. 

 

Tuesday, October 27, 2026

Ai Anomalies

 

        With the promise of Ai to be the greatest thing since sliced bread and the worst thing since the end of the world, I figured I should get my wish-list addressed before it is too late and they go public, raise the price and make trillions.  To begin with it should be Ai not AI which is confusing.  Who Is Al?  It is the same thing that 911 is not 9-1-1 and Jan 6 is not 1/6.  We must keep our disaster pivot points straight.  Call them by their real names.  It is not Super - Intelligence. Super is superfluous,  overused.  Meaningless.  Ai is Man Made, where the computer is just looking for the next correct word in a sentence.  And it learns.

        If we are going to sacrifice our water, energy, peace and quiet or peace of mind, we should get something out of these Ai data centers besides Bitcoin pricing and Fantasy Football odds.  At least until the massive centers are replaced by quantum computers, in five years, in frozen outer space, the size of R2-D2, that can calculate everything all at once.

        Not to be pedantic, but the first thing Ai can do is get rid of all our passwords.  It is so archaic, annoying and ineffective.  Like the TSA lines at the airport.  And get rid of all spam.  That’s stupid.  While you are at it, get rid of all typing, grammar and spelling.  It’s silly, in any language.  Put a USB port in your neck or Bluetooth, Wi-Fi in your head, and download your dictation, dreams and desires.  Make direct biological connections and cut out the middleman.  Then we can get on with winning wars, curing cancer and altzhimers, understanding the meaning of life, developing new math, the origin of the Universe, quantum entanglement and superposition, the belief in God gradient, the spectrums of our brains, defining and designing proteins, DNA, disease and do my taxes.  Is that too much to ask.



        Being a traffic guy, I would time all the traffic lights, all at once, everywhere, in real time, for maximum optimization of all of society, and me.  Attach it, predictively, to our maps programs to spread out the traffic around bottlenecks and utilize all the roads.  When the hockey game is out at the Delta Center, sense it and give every road a green wave out of town.  Include our billing rates, annual income, net worth and number of kids in our priority multipliers for the highest economic savings.  Better yet, get rid of drivers and have Ai drive all our cars for true safety and efficiency, connected to maps and people’s heads.  Better still, get rid of cars and have Ai dive our personal drones in am unlimited, three-dimensional grid or space.

        Being a water guy, I would have Ai follow all our storms and compute runoff, in real time, for better flood forecasting and warnings.  Also track the weather and all the models for better forecasts, including powder days, hurricanes, tornados, earthquakes, wind, heat, cold, humidity, smoke, fire, air quality, sun and moon shine.  Water supply and demand forecasting should be improved, and the price of water should affect this iteratively, with water being our newest and greatest commodity, besides clean air.  Deals could be made between farmers and chip producers, cities and cows.  Water can go to the best use or to the highest bidder, depending on your political persuasion. 

        Being a sports guy, I would get rid of referees and umpires and have instant replay review on everything.  Keep one guy around to tell them when to start or where to stand and for the managers to yell at but stop the charade of acceptable human error.  There is too much at stake for it to be humanly corruptible or randomly unpredictable.

        Being a truth guy, I would have instant facts check on everyone with a red light that goes on when they are lying.  Maybe get rid of crooked, non-representative politicians and let us all vote on every issue, instantly from our phones.  Get rid of middlemen in all walks of life and let us buy, sell and trade, stabilize markets, balance supply and demand, perfect the supply chain and curb our conspicuous consumption.

        Finally, there are the impossible things that cannot be solved yet, but we can try.  Like loading a dishwasher or airplane efficiently, processing legal immigration needs or reading my wife’s mind when she says nothing is wrong. How about doing the laundry, food shopping or adjusting our sprinklers.  We will need Ai to give us jobs, purpose and something to do.  It would be nice if Ai could end our divisiveness with an app that will connect people again who agree and disagree and not reinforce our differences.  Then we can decide what to do with Ai.