
We have been coming here to the Central Coast for 45 years and see both sides of the Morrow Bay Smokestack Issue. Should they stay or should they go.
We don’t know anything about
nothing but that is sometimes a valuable point with no bias or baggage.
Here are some back of the envelope Claude calculations for
installing some helix type wind mills up top. It could be a wind wind
situation. When they give you, lemons make lemonade.
To size the turbines and calculate the annual energy
output for all three Morro Bay stacks at 550 feet elevation (100
feet above the 450-foot stacks, assuming the stacks are topped by a
100-foot-tall spiral turbine), we combine commercial helical vertical-axis wind
turbine (VAWT) engineering limits with the 16 to 18 mph (~7.5 m/s) coastal
wind profile.
1. Sizing the Ideal Turbine for Each Stack
Because the stacks sit in a straight line roughly 120
to 150 feet apart, the rotor diameter cannot be so wide that the blades collide
or create severe wake turbulence. A 100-foot-tall lift-based helical
Darrieus turbine (similar to large-scale commercial VAWT concepts like
Quiet Revolution or IceWind / SeaTwirl scaled designs) is the sweet spot.
· Rotor Dimensions (per stack): 100 feet tall × 50 feet wide (30.5 m
× 15.2 m)
· Swept Area (per turbine): 5,000 sq. ft. (~465 sq. meters)
· Total Swept Area (all 3 stacks): 15,000 sq. ft. (~1,395 sq. meters)
· Rated Capacity (per turbine): 250 kW (reaching peak output in
~26–28 mph winds)
· Total Array Rated Capacity: 750 kW (0.75 MW)
· Cut-In / Cut-Out Speeds: Starts generating at 6 mph;
automatically brakes/feathers in extreme storm gusts above 55 mph.
2. Annual Energy Output Calculation (All 3 Stacks)
Wind turbines don't run at 100% peak capacity all year;
they operate at a Capacity Factor based on local wind
consistency. At 650 feet on the Central Coast—where afternoon thermal sea
breezes blow reliably from spring through fall—a 250 kW helical VAWT will
achieve an estimated 28% to 33% capacity factor.
Step-by-Step Energy Math:
1.
Available Wind
Power in the Air: At sea-level air
density ($\rho \approx 1.225\text{ kg/m}^3$) and a 17 mph (7.6 m/s) annual
average wind speed (accounting for standard Weibull wind speed distribution,
which boosts available energy above a flat average):
$$P_{\text{wind}} = \frac{1}{2} \rho A v^3 \times
\text{Weibull factor} \approx 260\text{ kW per turbine}$$
2.
Turbine
Efficiency ($C_p$): Lift-based helical
VAWTs capture roughly 32% to 35% of kinetic wind energy
(compared to ~45% for traditional three-blade horizontal turbines), yielding an
average continuous electrical output of~75 to 85 kW per stack.
3.
Annual
Production (8,760 hours/year):
o
Per Stack: $80\text{ kW} \times 8,760\text{ hours} \approx
\mathbf{700,000\text{ kWh}\ (700\text{ MWh})/year}$
o
All 3 Stacks
Combined: ~2,100,000 to
2,300,000 kWh (2.1 to 2.3 GWh) per year
3. Real-World Context: What 2.2 GWh/Year Powers
To put that output into perspective for Morro Bay:
|
Metric |
Estimated Output /
Impact |
|
Total Array Capacity |
750 kW (three 250 kW helical
turbines) |
|
Annual Electricity
Generated |
~2.1 to 2.3 GWh (2.2 million kWh) |
|
California Homes
Powered |
~320 to 500 homes continuously year-round (based
on average CA household usage of ~6,500 kWh/yr) – less at the coast with no
air condition |
|
Commercial Equivalent |
Roughly enough power
to run all of Morro Bay's Embarcadero waterfront businesses,
restaurants, and harbor operations |
|
Counter-Rotation Bonus |
Configuring the middle
turbine to spin opposite the outer two can reduce wake interference and boost
array efficiency by 5% to 10% (~2.4 GWh/yr total) |
4. Key Engineering & Cost Realities for a Proposal
If you are putting together a feasibility concept or
presentation, three practical numbers will ground your design:
· Estimated Capital Cost: Custom high-altitude commercial VAWT
installations of this scale typically run $3,500 per kW installed
(plus structural stack retrofitting), putting a three-stack project in
the $4 million range—a fraction of the estimated $20M+ cost to
demolish the stacks.
· Grid Advantage: Because the Morro Bay substation is immediately adjacent to the
stacks, interconnection costs would be minimal, and peak afternoon wind
generation aligns almost perfectly with California's peak afternoon/evening
electricity demand (when solar begins tapering off). No Batteries. Power
could also be coordinated with Diablo power plant.
I am sure they have considered something like this that
maybe has gotten lost in the noise but I urge you to reconsider. These
stacks can morph from historical eye sore to a functional attraction.
Painted pink and blue, tourist can charge their E-cars from the wind
while shopping in the green downtown.
I’m sure there are regulation challenges and dozens of
reasons and excuses not to do this but there is only one reason to do it. It
works. It makes sense. It would be fun
Costa Rica has made tourism marketing giant steps for
being a green country (without an army) and you could too. This could be
better than the Otters. When they give you mayo, make mayonnaise.
Make it so. Just do
it.
No comments:
Post a Comment